| 1st Team All-Americans |
| Student-Athlete |
Institution |
Position |
| Troy Ambros |
Penn State Greater Allegheny |
C |
| Joshua Arroyo |
Penn State Greater Allegheny |
1B |
| Brian Colon-Rodriguez |
Illinois Tech |
C/UTL |
| Derek Coy |
Penn State Mont Alto |
RHP |
| Austin Boos |
Illinois Tech |
INF |
| Bill Brancatella |
St. Joseph's (VT) |
P |
| Tom Osenbach |
Penn State Brandywine |
3B/RHP |
| Ryan Hendrickson |
Apprentice |
DH |
| Jayson Osborne |
St. Joseph's (VT) |
OF |
| Ryan Mummert |
Cincinnati-Clermont |
First Base |
| Ryan Akins |
Berea |
C/P |
| Blaise McCarty |
Penn State Beaver |
2B/3B |
| Aaron McGee |
Penn State Greater Allegheny |
MI/P |
| Michael Malfeo |
Illinois Tech |
P/C/INF |
| Sam Massie |
Apprentice |
P |
| |
|
|
| 2nd Team All-American |
| Student-Athlete |
Institution |
Position |
| Brandon Boyd |
Cincinnati-Clermont |
Pitcher |
| Matt Clark |
Penn State Mont Alto |
OF |
| Austin Southcott |
WVU Tech |
P/INF |
| Carlos Diaz |
WVU Tech |
OF |
| Alex Cline |
Penn State Mont Alto |
INF/RHP |
| Alan Madsen |
St. Joseph's (VT) |
P |
| Eddie Emes |
Penn State Greater Allegheny |
P |
| Brock Harris |
Apprentice |
OF |
| Mark Labrador |
Apprentice |
OF |
| Nick Casasanta |
Penn State Beaver |
1B/P |
| Jeff Burdett |
Iowa Wesleyan |
RHP |
| Zach Shannon |
Cincinnati-Clermont |
Pitcher |
| Dylan Harvey |
WVU Tech |
OF |
| Thomas McKenna |
St. Joseph's (Brkln) |
OF |
| Hunter Giles |
Tennessee Temple |
LHO |
| |
|
|
| Honorable Mention All-American |
| Student-Athlete |
Institution |
Position |
| Mitch Brigando |
St. Joseph's (Brkln) |
P/IF |
| Clayton Eberhardt |
Penn State Mont Alto |
OF |
| Nate Boyle |
Southern Maine CC |
P |
| Jake Debo |
Penn State Beaver |
2B/P |
| John Gorgone |
Penn State Brandywine |
OF |
| Kyle Bumpass |
Illinois Tech |
P/UTL |
| Chayancze Stirbis |
Iowa Wesleyan |
2B/SS |
| Christopher Carrano |
Briarcliffe (NY) |
OF |
| Wilson Matos |
SUNY Canton |
INF |
| Matt Roberts |
Penn State Schuylkill |
C/IF |
| Micah Wyatt |
Tennessee Temple |
RHP/UTIL |
| Ryan Hostrander |
Penn College |
P |
| Lawton Jackson |
Berea |
P |
| Phillip Langley |
Southern Maine CC |
P |
| Caden Shadrick |
Tennessee Temple |
IF |
| Blake German |
Rochester College |
OF/DH |
| Austin Forsythe |
Cleary |
IF |
| |
|
|
| Student-Athlete of the Year |
| Scott Kunert |
Rochester College |
|
| |
|
| Coach of the Year |
| Scott Marks |
Illinois Tech |
|
| |
|
| Player of the Year |
| Brian Colon-Rodriguez |
Illinois Tech |
|
